JUSTSUSS AI-powered press divergence analysis
2 outlets covered 2026.11.17 21:34 created
← Card Feed

Groundwork Collaborative Investigates Amazon Holiday Pricing

Report alleges deceptive pricing during major sales events.

Event Overview

The economic think tank Groundwork Collaborative released a report titled 'Deal or Decoy?' investigating Amazon's Black Friday and Cyber Monday sales in 2024 and 2025. The investigation analyzed over 350 products and found that nearly one in three advertised 'deals' offered no actual savings compared to prices in the preceding month.

Amazon has responded to the findings by stating that the report is deeply flawed and contains false claims.

Source facts (6)
1.

The report 'Deal or Decoy?' analyzed 351 unique products using Keepa pricing data.

Groundwork Collaborative
2.

29.1% of promoted deals offered no real savings compared to prices in the month prior.

Groundwork Collaborative
3.

9.4% of the analyzed deals were actually more expensive than previous prices.

Groundwork Collaborative
4.

Some items saw price increases ranging from 59% to 83%, including Hunter and UGG boots.

Groundwork Collaborative
5.

Nearly 60% of deals were no cheaper than prices offered in the preceding 10 to 90 days.

Groundwork Collaborative
6.

Lindsay Owens serves as the president and CEO of Groundwork Collaborative.

CBS News

Message Distribution

critical exposure An investigation by Groundwork Collaborative reveals that many of Amazon's advertised Black Friday and Cyber Monday 'deals' provided no savings or were actually more expensive than previous prices. 67%
2 articles
● Groundwork Collaborative — Deal or Decoy? Amazon’s Deceptive Discounts - Groundwork Collaborative
Message

A study of over 350 Amazon 'deals' found that nearly 1 in 3 provided no actual savings compared to prices in the preceding month.

● Groundwork Collaborative — Amazon’s Decoy Deals: Groundwork Investigation Reveals Nearly 1 in 3 Black Friday and Cyber Monday “Deals” Advertised by Amazon Offered No Savings to Shoppers, Nearly 1 in 10 Were Actually More Expensive - Groundwork Collaborative
Message

An investigation by Groundwork Collaborative reveals that many of Amazon's advertised Black Friday and Cyber Monday 'deals' provided no savings or were actually more expensive than previous prices.

factual relay The think tank Groundwork Collaborative alleges that Amazon's holiday deals are often deceptive, while Amazon denies these claims. 33%
1 articles
CBS News — Many of Amazon's Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals are often deceptive, think tank says
Message

The think tank Groundwork Collaborative alleges that Amazon's holiday deals are often deceptive, while Amazon denies these claims.

Editor's Analysis

The thin line between a holiday bargain and a pricing illusion

The dispute centers on whether holiday sale prices are genuine discounts or simply a marketing trick to create a false sense of urgency. Groundwork Collaborative claims that nearly one in three advertised deals offered no actual savings compared to the previous month, and some items even spiked in price by up to 83%. The think tank argues that this creates a deceptive environment for consumers already struggling with the cost of living.

Amazon disputes these findings, calling the report deeply flawed and based on false claims. The resolution of this conflict depends on the validity of the pricing data used and whether the observed price fluctuations fall within normal market volatility or constitute a systemic effort to mislead. If the data proves that prices were artificially inflated just to be lowered for the sale, the issue shifts from a business strategy to a consumer protection violation.

Data-driven exposure versus a brief summary

The coverage splits between those providing the evidence and those merely reporting the conflict. Groundwork Collaborative provides the necessary meat for the reader, detailing the use of Keepa pricing data and highlighting specific product categories like boots to show how the pricing gaps manifested. They go beyond the numbers to suggest a policy solution, calling for mandated disclosure of the lowest price from the previous 30 days.

In contrast, CBS News offers a high-level summary that frames the event as a 'he said, she said' dispute. While it introduces the key players, it omits the specific percentages and the methodology that make the claim concrete. The reader gets the gist of the fight, but only the original report provides the evidence needed to decide who is telling the truth.

Coverage flow

Coverage volume

11/16 · 2
11/17 · 1

Focus shift

11/16
Amazon
2
11/17
Amazon
1

Story timeline

11/16 Groundwork Collaborative investigates Amazon discounts
11/17 Groundwork Collaborative claims Amazon deals are deceptive

Recommended Reads

Loading comments...